The J Cote and Sons Excavating... Workplace Death. A Trench Collapse

By Mike Pearson
Over 1000 Canadian workers are killed every year. Pipelayer Jeff Caron was killed in a trench collapse on October 11 2012. He was 28 years old. A co-worker, Thomas Richer was badly injured in the very same cave-in.

 The trial against the company, J Cote Ecxavating of Langley BC and foreman David Green did not take place until 12 years had passed.

 12 nightmarish years for the family of Jeff Caron. The points I want to discuss here are... 1. Darn near every trench collapse death and injury is preventable.

 Making good decisions, spending the time and money to ensure worker safety will prevent ugly and traumatic deaths and injuries on construction work sites.

  2. At the December 2025 trial, judge Brundett found three senior officers of J Cote and Sons Excavating, guilty in the the 2012 death of Jeff Caron. 

 Jobsite foreman David Green was found not guilty of separate charges of manslaughter and criminal negligence.

 I disagree strongly with this decision. To paraphrase, the judge said that foreman David Green was not well trained enough nor held enough responsibilty to either make the decision to install a trench box for worker safety...or to stop the work when worker safety was in question.

 Bullshit, I say. David Green had plenty enough experience to know that a trench box, or trench sloping...or..an engineers certificate was required in the trench as deep as the one they were working in. { more on the engineer and certificate later...anothe pile of smelly bullshit}

 I have worked in construction for the bulk of my 50 year career.

 The number one reason that excavating contractors, pipelayers and utility contractors decide to forego safety protocols is ...THEY DONT THINK IT WILL HAPPEN TO THEM. 

 I have heard the actual words being bravely/stupidly uttered....ITS OK, I'LL BE QUICK. SO, DEATH IN A TRENCH COLLAPSW COMES QUICK...AND THE DIRT DOESN'T CARE WHO YOU ARE! WHAT IS A TRENCH BOX? I congratulate the BC Prosecuter's Office for being smarter and more aggresive than they were in the Sam Fitzpatrick / Kiewit Corporation workplace death case. Hats off to the investigators that pushed ahead to place blame where it belongs in Jeff Caron's very unneccesary workplace death. And to the judge, Michael Brundett who carefully sifted through all the information available to him and made a solid forward looking decision that will blaze the trail for future prosections of companiess that kill workers. Judge Brundett...I strongly disagree with your decision to let David Green sidestep the manslaughter and criminal negligence charges....I say ...better luck next time. The working foreman is the eyes and ears of the company management and ownership. The Engineer. This part of the story muddies the water. I'll let these news stories tell the sad and pathetic tale.
Burnaby workplace death trial: Engineer fined, investigated - Vancouver Is Awesome https://share.google/4gFXc7UiWgoq3gpDu

And other media reporting on the trench collapse and ensuing legal fight.

Burnaby workplace death trial: WorkSafeBC investigator testifies - Vancouver Is Awesome https://share.google/wEEgj1SvbqcUdXnzK

https://share.google/NpxPh24uPdj40fY7v Vancouver Sun A Rare Guilty Verdict in a Worker Fatality Case | The Tyee https://share.google/TK3OaKf1G8UjQOScW

IF YOU SEE SOMETHING UNSAFE....SAY SOMETHING

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Lost treasure trove of Abandoned Logging Machines....Part One

By Mike Pearson
Image
Canada Day 2012, what better way to celebrate than to go into the Canadian rain forest in search of lost mechanized treasures. The growth of the alder trees and underbrush was fairly intimidating, We only had hand tools, but faced a solid wall of green where we wanted to get into. We threw ourselves into the task for about half an hour and started to see good progress. That lead to hours more cutting,. pruning and dragging debris away. The results were definitely worth the effort, the hulking old logging gear was ready for it's close-up shot. Videos of the this site are here.. Press on the "YouTube" logo to get a bigger image. When you get to the YouTube site...then you can press the icon for "full screen" When you are done looking at these photos, and have a few minutes to spare...here is a link to a story that was on the front page of the Province newspaper on May 13 2012. It's a tale about a tragic workplace death of a friend of mine at Toba Inle...
Read more

The Mexican Billionaires Yacht, The Golden Cell

By Mike Pearson
Image
In the 90's I got into scuba diving to solve some problems at work. I had been  building docks,boathouses and the like for a few years (loved every minute of it)...when it came time to do various underwater chores...the divers that got hired were just not up to the task....they were good divers,but not great at working underwater. Keep in mind these are pre-regulation days in light commercial diving. The joys of work dives   frozen fresh water on top of sea water Diver Mike  So I decided ...I'll just do it myself. I signed up for a scuba course in Sechelt and met a man who would go on to be a huge factor in some great future times....Bill Brooks. I'll leave those tales for another time. Flash forward a few years...Bill and I have salvaged sunken boom boats, a slew of pleasure boats at the bottom of a damaged marina and had experimented with dives past 200ft.  By the time of this story rolls around I'm an establish local work diver. In the cou...
Read more

Scaling Bar for an Excavator

By Mike Pearson
Image
From time to time, the usual attachments and ideas don't work anymore. Scaling loose rock at the max reach and height of an excavator boom/stick is dangerous and nerve racking work. The possibility of doing damage to the machine, and having a chunk of rock come through you window are fairly high. Here are a few pics of a successful design of a scaling bar attachment that was built for 345/450 sized machines. The thick wall round tube design is much stronger and rigid than any size of I-beam or H-beam designs. I have used I/H-beam scaling bars...and the first thing they do is flex like a wet spaghetti noodle. We had a 12 inch I-beam bar on a 200 Hitachi, and it bent easily with very little torque applied. The round  model in the photos has a replaceable tube that is held in by a pin. Here's a few things that I have learned about excavator scaling bars. 1. It's dangerous work. b. Put your best guy on the job c. Put you ugliest machine under him ( you will hit the ...
Read more